Old vs New Regime Threshold
Switch to old regime if deductions exceed ₹4.5L
What is This Hack?
Switch to old regime if total deductions (80C+80D+HRA+24b) exceed ₹4.5 lakh for ₹25 lakh income, otherwise new regime saves more
How It Works
From FY 2023-24, the new tax regime became the default, offering lower tax rates but eliminating most deductions (80C, 80D, HRA, 24b home loan interest, etc.). The big question: Should you switch back to old regime? The answer depends on your total eligible deductions. Rule of thumb: For ₹25 lakh income, if your deductions exceed ₹4.5 lakh, old regime saves more tax. For ₹15 lakh income, threshold is around ₹2.5 lakh deductions. For ₹10 lakh income, new regime almost always wins. Why? Old regime has higher tax rates but allows ₹1.5L (80C) + ₹25K (80D) + HRA + ₹2L (24b) + other deductions. New regime has lower rates but only standard deduction (₹75K from FY 25-26). The crossover point varies by income level. Most salaried employees with home loans, 80C investments, and HRA benefit from old regime. Freelancers, those without deductions, or low-income earners benefit from new regime.
Step-by-Step Implementation
Calculate Total Eligible Deductions
List all deductions available to you in old regime: Section 80C: ₹1.5L (PPF, ELSS, EPF, life insurance, principal), Section 80D: ₹25K (health insurance, ₹50K if senior citizen), HRA: Calculate exempt portion (use our HRA calculator), Section 24b: Home loan interest up to ₹2L, Section 80CCD(1B): NPS ₹50K extra, Others: 80G donations, 80E education loan, 80TTA/TTB interest. Total these amounts.
Use Income Tax Calculator for Both Regimes
Use our Income Tax Calculator. Input: Gross salary, Total deductions (calculated above). Calculate tax in OLD regime (with deductions) and NEW regime (without deductions, only standard deduction). Compare final tax liability.
Apply Threshold Decision Framework
Income ₹10L: New regime almost always wins. Income ₹15L: Old regime if deductions > ₹2.5L. Income ₹20L: Old regime if deductions > ₹3.5L. Income ₹25L: Old regime if deductions > ₹4.5L. Income ₹50L: Old regime if deductions > ₹8L. Higher income needs proportionately higher deductions for old regime to win.
Consider Future Deductions
Planning to buy house? Future home loan interest makes old regime attractive. Kids education expenses? 80C limit helps. Retiring soon? NPS 80CCD benefits. Choose regime considering 2-3 year horizon, not just current year.
Declare Regime to Employer
By start of FY (April) or when joining, inform employer which regime you choose. This affects monthly TDS deduction. You can change regime at ITR filing time, but better to declare early for correct TDS.
Opt for Old Regime in ITR if Beneficial
When filing ITR, explicitly opt for old regime if that saves more tax. In ITR form, select "Opted for taxation under section 115BAC" = No (means old regime). Claim all eligible deductions. Attach investment proofs.
Review Annually
Regime choice can change year to year based on: Income changes, Life events (marriage, home purchase), Deduction availability. Recalculate every year in March-April before ITR filing.
Real Example: Software Engineer with Home Loan
Situation
Priya earns ₹25 lakh gross salary. HRA: ₹8L. She pays ₹1.8L rent (lives in Bangalore). Home loan interest: ₹2L. Investments: PPF ₹1.5L, health insurance ₹25K. Total deductions: HRA exemption ₹1.8L + 80C ₹1.5L + 80D ₹25K + 24b ₹2L = ₹5.55 lakh.
Without This Hack
Priya stays in new regime (default): Gross ₹25L. Standard deduction ₹75K. Taxable: ₹24.25L. Tax (new regime rates): ₹5.85 lakh + cess = ₹6.1 lakhs. She doesn't realize she could save more by switching.
With This Hack
Priya calculates both: Old regime: ₹25L - ₹5.55L deductions - ₹50K standard deduction = ₹18.95L taxable. Tax (old rates): ₹4.36L + cess = ₹4.54 lakh. New regime: Tax = ₹6.1L (as above). Old regime saves: ₹6.1L - ₹4.54L = ₹1.56 lakh! She opts for old regime in ITR. Her deductions (₹5.55L) exceed threshold (₹4.5L), so old regime wins.
💰 ₹1.56 lakh annual tax saving by choosing correct regime
Common Pitfalls to Avoid
- Don't blindly choose new regime because it's default - calculate first
- Regime choice is annual - can change every year, don't lock into one thinking it's permanent
- Some deductions (employer NPS 80CCD(2)) are available in BOTH regimes - don't count those in comparison
- If you have variable income (bonuses, freelancing), recalculate regime choice when income changes
- For senior citizens, thresholds are different due to higher basic exemption and 80D limits
- Agricultural income, if any, affects slab rates in old regime but not in new regime
- Salary arrears/leave encashment may push you into higher slabs - affects regime choice
Prerequisites & Requirements
- Any taxpayer with salary or business income
- Access to deduction details (80C investments, HRA, home loan interest, etc.)
- Use Income Tax Calculator to compare both regimes accurately
- Understand your income level and corresponding deduction threshold
- Declare regime choice to employer for correct TDS (optional but recommended)
- Explicitly opt for old regime in ITR if choosing that
- Review decision annually based on income and deduction changes
- Maintain deduction proofs if opting for old regime
Key Benefits
- Potential savings: ₹50,000-2 lakhs
- Implementation time: 1 hour
- Legal status: fully legal
- Risk level: low